I absolutely love this eyeliner! It's waterproof. It goes on great. It's not expensive and I will buy it over and over and over again. I also bought the brown one. I would recommend this eyeliner to anyone and everyone.

I am genuinely impressed by how well this stays put. I have slightly oily eyelids and most liquid liners start to smudge or stamp onto my upper eyelid by lunch time. This one dries fast and doesn't budge for tensile hours. It's true. It's a true deep saturated plaque that doesn't fade to gray as the day goes on for a drugstore price. The staying power is incredible.

I am genuinely impressed by how well this stays put. I have slightly oily eyelids and most liquid liners start to smudge or stamp onto my upper eyelid by lunch time. This one dries fast and doesn't budge for tensile hours. It's true. It's a true deep saturated plaque that doesn't fade to gray as the day goes on for a drugstore price. The staying power is incredible

Probably my most favorite eyeliner that I have purchased in a very long time. I work in a very hot and humid environment, and my makeup stays all day with this particular eyeliner pen. The application is very easy, and it does not feel like it is drying out. When applying the lines, it does not leave smear marks that you have to go over multiple times

The best eye liner by far. Easy to apply and stays all day. Just make sure the cap actually snaps on it it's popping off and your drying out asap. It's the only one that doesn't irritate my eyes. It's bold and bright and doesn't smear or flake off and the tip is helpful in making fine lines and doesn't drag on the skin

Affordable liquid eyeliner that doesn’t smear easily or disappear from water. Easy to remove. Love this stuff.

Let me tell you, I am NOT a crier, but I had the roughest day at work today, and carefully dabbed at my eyes so I wouldn't ruin my makeup, since I don't bring everything with me to work. You can see, my mascara is nearly gone, my eyeshadows are blotchy, but this eyeliner?? Only the SLIGHTEST of budging! This isn't the review I thought I would write, but it held up!

I had worn the same liquid eyeliner for decades and then it was discontinued. My search left me with smeared black eyes, making me look like I had been crying all the time. Thankfully, I found this eyeliner. It works like a charm—no smudges and no smearing. It is water-resistant for me. I’ll be a repeat customer. I love it!

This is a really great liquid eyeliner. The brush is easy to work with, I was able to get a really thin line on my lash line and do a little wing. I found it did drag just a bit. It dries down quickly and has a matte finish. It still looked really nice after wearing it all day, it started to crack a little but I only noticed it when I got up close to the mirror. Highly recommend!